Pink Floyd

changeling

changeling

A Rock God
Even the Final Cut and Division Bell respectively are waaaaaay better than The Wall.
 
Floyd

Floyd

Administrator
Staff member
I have to disagree.
I like Syd, Gilmour and Waters , let's say, 100%, 60% and 80% respectively....I mean, it's not that I disdain any of them....but as a band, PF started off as a psychedelic band that lost its way down the line until it got totally lost with The wall :) 🤣
My ratings would be 20% Barret, 100% Gilmore 60% Waters. I am of the opinion that if Gilmore's did not join with his unique voice and guitar playing style, Pink Floyd would have died.
 
changeling

changeling

A Rock God
∆∆∆∆∆ I see your point , but we can also put it this way: if Gilmour had formed Pink Floyd together with the other original members instead of Syd, well, Pink Floyd would never have been created as we know and admire it :)
 
changeling

changeling

A Rock God
This is for the "newbies" here like Justin:
the way the other members treated Syd after he left the band (better still, ousted from the band), will never be justifiable in the mind of Floyd's die-hard fans. Alright, so Syd had drug addiction problems, but he wasn't insane like they said he was.
They didn't even recognize Syd when he walked into the recording studio one day !!! This, my friends, is totally unforgivable !
 
Forum Community

Adminstrator Moderator Member Fanatic

Top